New Jersey & Virginia Offices · Serving All 50 States

J. v. Edlow U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Michigan Filed October 16, 2026

Five months without a decision on a work permit. Nineteen days after a federal lawsuit, it was approved.

USCIS approved our client’s work permit on November 4, 2026, 19 days after we filed in the Eastern District of Michigan. The government had 60 days to respond in court. Its lawyer entered the case only after the approval, and the case closed on day 28. This is the story of those four weeks, told from the court record.

This case on a calendar

  1. May 2026Application filed with USCIS
  2. About 5 monthsWaiting at USCIS
  3. October 16, 2026, day 0Lawsuit filed
  4. October 21, day 5Government served
  5. November 4, day 19USCIS approves the work permit
  6. November 13, day 28Notice filed, case closed

The 28 days in court, up close

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances. A mandamus lawsuit asks the court to require a decision. It does not guarantee approval.

Illustration: a window seat on a rainy autumn afternoon, with a phone lying face-down, a cup of tea and a closed book on a knit blanket
Illustration.

A mandamus lawsuit gives the government 60 days to respond in court. In this case, USCIS answered the question that mattered, the application itself, in 19.

May 2026 to October 2026

Five months, and no decision

Our client is from India and lives in the United States. In May 2026, they filed Form I-765 with USCIS, the application for a work permit.

Summer came and went, and the case status did not change. A pending work permit has no deadline of its own, so there was no date to plan around.

October 14, 2026

“Is five months long enough?”

In mid-October, our client hired us. Five months is shorter than many of the waits we see, and the first question was a fair one: is it long enough for a lawsuit?

There is no fixed number. A mandamus lawsuit does not ask a judge to approve an application. It asks the court to require USCIS to make a decision within a reasonable time. Courts weigh that under what are known as the TRAC factors, which look at how long the agency has taken and at what the delay is doing to the person waiting.

We reviewed the file and filed the lawsuit two days later.

October 16, 2026, day 0

Filing in Michigan, and a 60-day clock

We filed J. v. Edlow in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan. The defendant was Joseph B. Edlow, the Director of USCIS, sued in his official capacity. The complaint asked the court, under the federal mandamus law, 28 U.S.C. § 1361, to require USCIS to decide the application.

The court issued the summonses the same day and assigned the case to a district judge and a magistrate judge. Five days later, on October 21, 2026, the papers were served on the U.S. Attorney’s office for the district. That started the government’s 60-day period to respond. Its deadline was December 21, 2026.

Illustration: a red-brick courthouse with a clock tower at dusk, framed by red and orange autumn trees
Illustration. Not the courthouse where this case was filed.
November 4, 2026, day 19

Day 19: the approval

On November 4, the nineteenth day, USCIS approved the work permit. Up to that point, the government had not filed a single document in the case, and its deadline to respond was still almost seven weeks away.

The court never had to rule on anything. The lawsuit asked for a decision, and USCIS made one.

Illustration: a frosty train platform at sunrise, with a pair of gloves and a laptop bag on a wooden bench
Illustration.
November 13, 2026, day 28

Day 28: the case closes

Five days after the approval, on November 9, 2026, an attorney for the government filed a notice of appearance. It was the government’s first filing in the case. A notice of appearance tells the court who will represent the agency. It does not respond to the complaint, and no response ever followed.

On November 13, 2026, we filed a notice of voluntary dismissal. It put the approval on the record:

On November 4, 2026, 19 days after this action was filed, USCIS approved the application. Plaintiff has therefore obtained the relief sought in the Complaint, and no further action by the Court is necessary.
Notice of Voluntary Dismissal, filed November 13, 2026

Because the government had not filed an answer or a motion for summary judgment, the notice closed the case the day it was filed. No court order was needed, and the case ended more than five weeks before the government’s deadline to respond.

Looking back

About five months at USCIS before we filed. Two days from hiring us to filing, 19 days from filing to approval, and 28 days to a closed case. The government’s lawyer arrived after the decision had already been made.

The government had 60 days to answer. USCIS decided in 19.

What this case shows, and what it doesn’t

What it shows

  • A work permit application that has stopped moving can be decided soon after a federal lawsuit is filed. Here, USCIS approved it 19 days later.
  • The 60 days are the government’s time to respond in court, not a waiting period for a decision. Here, the approval came with 47 days to spare.
  • A government attorney entering the case does not mean a fight is coming. Here, the attorney appeared after the approval, and the case closed four days later without an answer.

What it doesn’t promise

  • Five months is not a magic number. A delay can be found reasonable, and the facts of each case decide.
  • A lawsuit asks the court to require a decision. USCIS decides the application on its merits, and no lawyer can promise approval.
  • One case is not a forecast. In our 2026 filings, the median time from filing to a USCIS decision has been about 30 days.

Results may vary depending on your particular facts and legal circumstances. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

See the paperwork for yourself

The dismissal notice we filed, with our client’s name, the case number, the court’s division and the judge’s name covered.

Notice of Voluntary Dismissal

Filed November 13, 2026, docket #7

Name and case number covered View document

What we covered, and why

Our client’s name, the case number, the court’s division and the judge’s name. The text of the notice, its date and the attorney’s signature block stay visible.

Why we don’t link to the court record

Federal court records show a client’s full name. To protect our client’s privacy, we leave out the case name, the case number and the judge’s name, and we don’t link to the docket.

Arif Gozel, managing attorney at Gozel Law Firm PC

The attorney who filed J. v. Edlow

Arif Gozel, Esq.

Managing Attorney, Gozel Law Firm PC

Arif Gozel’s federal practice is built around one problem: immigration cases that have stopped moving. He prepared and filed this lawsuit himself and signed the notice that closed it.

This case was filed in Michigan, hundreds of miles from our offices in New Jersey and Virginia. Each case is filed in the federal court that best fits it, so you don’t need to live near us.

Federal lawsuits filed in 2026
More than 500
Federal district courts filed in
57
Admitted to practice
New York (2019), Maryland (2020), New Jersey (2023)
Works with clients in
English, Spanish and Turkish

Months into waiting on a work permit? Let’s look at your case together.

Send us your receipt date and, if you have one, the end date on your current card. Within 24 hours, we’ll tell you whether a federal lawsuit makes sense now, later, or not at all.

  • Your work permit application has been pending for months, and the status hasn’t changed.
  • You’ve contacted USCIS, and nothing moved.
  • You’re not sure whether your wait is long enough for a lawsuit.

Flat $5,000 for a typical case, plus the $405 federal filing fee. Your current immigration attorney keeps handling the application.

Questions about the first weeks of a case

Is five months long enough to sue USCIS?
There is no fixed number. Courts look at whether a delay is unreasonable, and under the TRAC factors they also weigh what it is doing to your health, welfare and finances. In this case, our client filed after about five months, and USCIS approved the work permit 19 days later. Whether your wait is enough depends on your facts, which is what the free review is for.
What happens after a mandamus lawsuit is filed?
The court issues summonses, and the papers are served on the U.S. Attorney’s office, the Attorney General and USCIS. Service on the U.S. Attorney’s office starts the government’s 60-day period to respond. In this case, that happened five days after filing, and USCIS approved the work permit on day 19, long before the deadline.
What does it mean when a government attorney files a notice of appearance?
It tells the court which attorney will represent the agency. It is not an answer and does not argue anything about the case. In this case, the government’s attorney appeared on day 24, after the approval, and the government never filed an answer or a motion.
How long does a mandamus case take?
It depends on the case. In this one, USCIS approved the work permit 19 days after we filed, and the case closed on day 28. In our 2026 filings, the median time from filing to a USCIS decision has been about 30 days, and some cases take longer.
Do I need to live near my lawyer?
No. Federal lawsuits are filed electronically, and most mandamus cases are handled entirely in writing. This case was filed in Michigan by our New Jersey office, and there was no hearing.
Can the government ask the court to dismiss the case?
Yes. The government can answer the lawsuit or file a motion to dismiss it. Responding to a motion to dismiss is not included in our flat fee. In this case, the government did neither.

Sources: Federal court record, U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan. Case name and number withheld to protect our client’s privacy.

Published . Last updated .

Chat with us on WhatsApp